Below is a complete reader's report on a fictional submission — nothing withheld. Then run one real evaluation on material of your own: free, no account, nothing saved.
Drop the PDF the author sent, or paste the synopsis. Title, author, genre and synopsis are pulled straight out of the text.
A structured reader's report: logline, synopsis, themes, comps, adaptation angle, 18 scored criteria and a pass / consider / recommend verdict.
Filter by category, status, verdict or genre — or search the whole pile by concept, like "books about lawyers falling in love".
Sample reader's report
Ines Halvorsen · Literary suspense · via Beacon & Vale Literary
Scores run 1-10 across 18 criteria, grouped into four pillars — fit to list, manuscript quality, commercial signal and the author — each with a one-sentence note behind it.
When a court stenographer starts transcribing confessions that were never spoken aloud, she has ten days to decide whether to save a man she believes is guilty.
Marit Sundby has spent nineteen years making other people's words permanent. A stenographer in a mid-sized Norwegian district court, she is precise, unremarkable, and quietly unravelling after the death of her brother. During the trial of a fisherman accused of killing his business partner, Marit begins to hear a second voice in the courtroom — calm, unhurried, and confessing things no witness has said. The transcript she produces each night contains sentences she has no memory of typing. As the trial narrows toward a verdict, Marit tests the voice against the case file and finds it disturbingly accurate about details never entered into evidence. Her attempts to raise the discrepancy make her a liability: the defence wants her testimony, the prosecution wants her replaced, and the judge wants the record clean. The novel tightens over ten court days, alternating trial transcript with Marit's fraying private account, until she must choose between the version of the truth the system can use and the one she believes. The ending withholds the supernatural explanation and delivers a moral one instead.
The gate
Sits cleanly on the literary-suspense shelf with credible Nordic-noir crossover.
Comparable titles are recent, sold well, and match both voice and packaging.
Defined and reachable through book clubs, libraries, and translated-crime readers.
The read
Confessions no one spoke is a one-line premise that sells itself.
Cool, exact, faintly clinical — consistent across both narrative registers.
Spare sentences with a controlled rhythm; almost no wasted description.
Ten-day frame drives well; the middle three days repeat their own tension.
Marit's grief is specific and load-bearing; the defendant stays underwritten.
Familiar courtroom furniture put to an unfamiliar, restrained purpose.
Structural trim of roughly 12k words in the middle act; line-level is clean.
Inbound — judged on manuscript
Translated and Nordic-adjacent suspense continues to perform in trade.
Marit could carry a second book, though the premise resists repetition.
Strong film/TV and audio potential; the transcript device is audio-native.
Platform, credentials, track record
Audience
Adult readers of literary suspense and translated crime — the Tana French / Kate Atkinson overlap. Skews female, 35-65, library-heavy, strong book-club and Nordic-noir crossover.
Comparable titles
Unreliable professional narrator inside an institution; commercial suspense packaging with literary voice.
Procedural frame carrying a psychological unravelling; comparable pacing and prose register.
Nordic literary strangeness held just short of the fantastic — same tonal restraint.
European mid-century melancholy with a wide trade readership; useful positioning comp for jacket and pitch.
Viability
high
Format
Six-part limited series
Budget
mid
Hooks
Risks
Verdict
A distinctive, controlled literary suspense with a genuinely sellable premise and unusually strong subsidiary-rights value. The manuscript needs a structural trim in the middle act, not a rewrite. Recommend reading with an offer in mind; the adaptation angle is the strongest part of the case.
Sample report on a fictional manuscript. The author pillar is unscored because no author background was supplied.
Paste a synopsis, a query letter, or the opening pages. Nothing is saved — sign up to keep reports in your pipeline.
At least 120 characters needed.
Upload the PDFs as they arrive, score them against your own list and taste, and search the whole pipeline by concept.
Start reading